I do believe, there is nothing more wonderful at Christmas than hurrying home to the family, into a kitchen hopefully bestrewed with fairy lights and glittery decorations galore and being offered a freshly baked and still warm mince pie. A blob of brandy butter if I’m not the designated driver for me, please!

Each year, magazines do roundups of which shop is selling the best mince pie but honestly, once you crack your own, you will never be able to have the boxed versions without feeling disappointed. I’ve tried many a version over the years, looking for my idea of the perfect pie and now I think – enough tinkering! It’s time to share my Mince Pies with Cream Cheese Pastry.


Rather than being a bit cynical about people trying to reinvent the wheel, I think of the 1.5 million hits you get from Googling “mince pie recipe” as a sign of enthusiasm for this traditional festive treat and rejoice in there being a perfect recipe out there for us all. My idea of perfection starts with the ratio of filling to pastry – I like the mincemeat to be a flavouring for the pastry, rather than the pastry being a carry case for a ton of spiced and boozy fruits.

This year, I treated myself to some round bottomed mince pie tins which are super cheap (so definitely buy two!), give the cute and delicate rounded shape to my pies plus are small enough to fit two trays into a domestic oven side by side so you can make all 24 in one go.

The pastry I use is something which is much more popular over in America from the food blogs and cookbooks I’ve read but really, we Brits need to start making much more of it! It’s a sweet shortcrust pastry with some full-fat cream cheese worked right in.

If you have struggled with getting your shortcrust tender and flaky enough, then this is pastry for you. Yes, it’s rich but it’s Christmas! Eat your pie, enjoy yourself! Honestly, I’ve turned so many “mince pie haters” with my pies and I think the pastry is what clinches the deal. Just make sure you do not over-bake it – these pies are meant to be pale – an overcooked mince pie is so disappointing. No less because it makes them harder to reheat if they aren’t all eaten soon after baking.


As for the mincemeat, again, it’s taken years to settle on the perfect recipe and I really believe that Hettie’s Suet Free Mincemeat from Nigella’s How to be a Domestic Goddess is spot on.

My friend Nicola encouraged me to try it years ago and I’ve never looked back since. It’s rich and boozy but has a wonderfully soft texture – that being one of the failings of the store-bought versions, jaggedly sharp and dried up fruit. This is all luxury and it tastes superb.

I have made minor adjustments over the years to the recipe, but they are genuinely really small tweaks as it’s so good as it stands. I do grind my own Mixed Spice but lately, I’ve been using my own home ground Pumpkin Pie Spice in its place for my Christmas Cake and Christmas Puddings and I love it.

How to make your own pumpkin pie spice - easy peasy and utterly delicious in lots of home baked goodies

Pumpkin Pie Spice

Adding a little extra booze is no bad idea if you plan on making a big batch of mincemeat and storing some, even for next year as it mellows a lot as it matures. To finish my mince pies, I like to brush half with milk and sprinkle with a generous amount of caster sugar before baking and the other half, I sprinkle with a heavy but freshly fallen cloud of icing sugar just as they are served. How would you have yours

Mince Pies with Cream Cheese Pastry
Tender melt in the mouth pastry cases thanks to the cream cheese, filled generously with homemade mincemeat.
Servings: 24
: 104 kcal
Author: Just Jo
For the pastry
  • 300 g plain flour
  • 1 tsp baking powder
  • 75 g caster sugar
  • 100 g soft butter
  • 100 g full fat cream cheese
  • 1 large egg
To fill
  • 1 small jar of mincemeat
To finish
  • Milk to brush
  • Caster or icing sugar to sprinkle
  • A 12-hole tart tin/bun tray with round bottoms*
  • A small star shaped cookie cutter or plunger cutter optional
  1. I make my pastry in the food mixer by pulsing together the flour, baking powder, sugar, butter and cream cheese until it forms a crumbly texture then I add in the egg and pulse again until it comes together in a ball. Scoop onto some clingfilm and chill for a minimum of an hour before using.
  2. If making by hand, rub the butter into the flour then stir in the baking powder and sugar. Use a dinner knife to cut in the cream cheese and then bring together using the egg. Whichever way you go, don't over handle the pastry and stop just before it comes together.
  3. Preheat oven to 180˚C.
  4. Work with half the pastry at a time, keeping one half in the fridge. Roll out to approximately 2-3mm thick and stamp out circles of pastry big enough to line your tart tin* and press into the tin. Add a spoonful of mincemeat (don't over fill) then stamp out circles of pastry just big enough to cover each tart and cut out a star with your small cutter before placing on top of the tart and pressing lightly to seal. Brush with milk and sprinkle generously with extra caster sugar.
  5. Bake for 20 minutes until the pastry is dry to the touch but at most, pale golden brown - these little pies aren't meant to be very brown when baked.
  6. Cool on a rack for 10 minutes to allow them to firm up and then pop each one out onto a rack to finish cooling. If you have only one tin, make the second batch in the same way.
  7. If you prefer, you don't need to sprinkle with caster sugar before baking and instead, can dust liberally with icing sugar to serve.
Recipe Notes

*= I use an old fashioned tart tin which gives small round bottomed tarts. A fairy cake tin is a very similar size but if you use a muffin tin, they will be almost twice as big and will require up to an extra 10 minutes cooking time plus you should expect to only get 12 out of the stated quantities.

This post contains affiliate links, meaning I will earn a little commission if you chose to buy items I’ve advertised, helping me to bring you all these recipes for free!

Like this post? Then why not try these related recipes: