Garlic Mushroom, Feta and Cherry Tomato Tart

I love cake,  I do.  Making it, reading about it, photographing it, talking about it, feeding it to people, eating it.  Pure joy.  All of it.  Alas one can not subsist on cake alone and therefore I have to devise ways to get my bake on without ladling out cupfuls of sugar and slabs of butter.  Sigh, if only you could take the calories out of cake as Cameron Diaz dreams the object of her affections Peter does in The Sweetest Thing.  Tell me you haven’t had that dream too… ;)

As May draws to a close, the weather has turned and we are having glorious sun filled skies on a daily basis which always inspire me to get my exercise gear on as well as eating lighter, fresher more colourful foods.  Gone are the comforting carbs and their dowdy wheaten hues, enter in mounds of spritely summery veg.  Dare I say it but I am even tempted away from the cake tin by the emergence of summer fruits.  Oh how I love a succulent British strawberry and oh my, are the early arrivals turning out to be excellent this year already.  However, I digress.  We have tarts for tea to talk about…

Several years ago, I watched Rachel Allen’s TV series Bake. I loved every episode. Not only because it was filled with recipes of hers I really wanted to make immediately but also because each episode showcased the work of both up and coming baking stars and long-established baking legends. The girls behind my beloved Primrose Bakery, the two fabulous Davids of Outsider Tart, the cheeky chappy Gerhard Jenne of Konditor & Cook were all featured amongst others I don’t have time to wax lyrical about. Apart from Isadora Popovic of The Popina Bakery and her (in my opinion) innovative quiches using a light bread dough rather than rich, buttery and decadent shortcrust pastry.

As divine as the traditional may be, a summer dinner it is not and together with all the voluptuous savoury custard usually incorporating much heavy cream, it really isn’t for the calorie conscious.  So I scaled down her recipe as you really don’t need as much as the original states and created a savoury summer tart which we could have for dinner one night after work, wrap up and take on a weekend picnic or freeze for when hunger strikes but the thought of standing stoveside for more than 5 minutes makes you want to scream.

If you’ve never made a quiche or savoury tart before you will be thrilled with how much more taste you get in making it yourself.  Here, I make garlic mushrooms and used some feta which had been marinading in the fridge (covered in olive oil, oregano and chilli flakes and in a sterilised jar – mine never lasts more than a week as we eat it all!).

You’d think garlic and mushroom were rather heavy flavours for my hot-weather inspired meal but when you add in plump cherry tomatoes which burst upon biting and sizeable chunks of the salty, sharp goat and sheep milk Greek cheese all the flavours compliment rather than compete.  Spring onions are great for giving that characteristic onion flavour but in a fresher, almost herby-chive-like manner.  I love ’em so I put a ton in.  That jade green colour is just so visually appealing too :D

garlic mushroom, feta & tomato quiche

To make the filling less heavy I like to use low-fat Greek yogurt and single cream with a higher egg proportion.  Sounds a bit counterintuitive but the full-fat quiches will use a heap of double cream and far less egg to “set” the savoury custard.  Now I do love me some double cream but when eaten in such a vast quantity, it takes the joy out of eating it – a spoon or two on top of a hot pudding-like apple pie is how I like to get my hit.

Using a bit more egg helps with the runnier, higher water content yogurt and single cream in getting it to set.  I have also subbed the whole amount with reduced fat sour cream too – work out the calories if you must and see which sounds like the lesser of two evils!  Then dig in and don’t give a damn because it’s so delicious, you can always go for a run when the sun goes down ;)

garlic mushroom, feta & tomato quiche

Hungry Hubby loves his with baked beans, I like mine with a fresh green salad.  Which I put on his plate too so he *has* to eat them as he won’t leave food on his plate.  The things you learn after almost 14 years together mwuahahaha ;)  Also, we prefer to eat our quiches cold but I know the very idea of this makes others recoil in horror – please so feel free to snaffle it up as soon as it comes out of the oven.

I do have a real weakness for baked feta as you may see from my regular snaps of dinner on Facebook.  It sneaks into a sometimes frightening amount of dishes!  However you like to eat it, please do try it and tell me all about it.  I love to hear how folk get on with my recipes so don’t be shy and leave me a comment.  Fiddling with my recipes is wholeheartedly encouraged :D

garlic mushroom, feta & tomato quiche

5 from 1 vote
Garlic Mushroom, Feta and Cherry Tomato Tart
Servings: 6
: 334 kcal
Author: Just Jo
For the base
  • 180 g strong bread flour
  • 1 medium egg
  • Approx 60-75ml water
  • 1 level tsp dried yeast
  • 1 tbsp olive oil
  • Salt and pepper
For the filling
  • 200-300 g baby button mushrooms
  • 1 large clove of garlic minced
  • 1 tsp olive oil
  • 6 spring onions finely sliced
  • 2 handfuls of cherry tomatoes approx 200-250g
  • 150 g feta marinated feta is fabulous here
  • 80 g greek yogurt low fat is fine
  • 120 ml single or double cream
  • 3 medium eggs
  • 1/2 tsp dried thyme
  • 1/4 tsp dried oregano
  • Good grating of fresh nutmeg
  • 1/4 tsp dried basil you may use fresh if dried horrifies you!
  1. Make the pastry base by kneading all the dough ingredients together until smooth and not sticky – add a little more flour if it is sticky or all the water if too dry. Cover with a piece of cling film whilst you prepare the filling.
  2. Heat the oil for the filling and add your mushrooms (leave them whole) and cook until they release their juices at which time, quickly stir in the garlic and spring onions. Follow with the fried thyme and oregano. Cook until the onions are softened, not browned. Put to once side to cool.
  3. Roll out your pastry 2-3cm larger than your loose bottomed tart tin – mine is 23cm in diameter. Transfer to the tin and gently mould to the sides of the tin. Use your thumb to “cut” the excess pastry off against the rim of the tin.
  4. Add the cooled vegetables then slice your cherry tomatoes in half and add them on top. Cube or tear up your feta as you like and scatter over the top too – try and insure the future slices will have an equal amount of all the filling main ingredients. It will look like there isn;t enough but don’t panic – the custard is coming! Albeit a savoury one…
  5. Measure the yogurt, cream, eggs and nutmeg into a jug and whisk until well combined but not frothy. Pour over the vegetables and sprinkle with the dried basil, if using. I suggest using fresh on top after it is cooked if you have an aversion to dried herbs.
  6. Bake in a preheated oven at 180°C for 30-35 mins until the filling is puffed up, browned in places and the pastry is shrinking away from the tin. It will puff up quite a bit with those three eggs.
  7. Cool in the tin for 15 minutes then remove from the tin, slide off the base and then cool on a rack. Cut into portions and when completely cool, wrap well in cling film then foil if freezing. If not, wrap in cling film and it will keep in the fridge for 2 days. Return to room temp before eating or pop in a moderate oven to warm through if liked.
Nutrition Facts
Garlic Mushroom, Feta and Cherry Tomato Tart
Amount Per Serving
Calories 334 Calories from Fat 171
% Daily Value*
Total Fat 19g 29%
Saturated Fat 9g 45%
Cholesterol 159mg 53%
Sodium 337mg 14%
Potassium 272mg 8%
Total Carbohydrates 26g 9%
Dietary Fiber 1g 4%
Sugars 2g
Protein 14g 28%
Vitamin A 14.5%
Vitamin C 4.7%
Calcium 18%
Iron 7.7%
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet.
Every Nook & Cranny favicon

Subscribe today and never miss a recipe!

Join the EN&C mailing list today!



  1. Holly Connors 21/05/2014 at 09:06 - Reply

    Mmm cake… Although this looks pretty great too. Love the step by step pics to help along the way. Sounds like something I need to try :)

    • Jo Blogs 21/05/2014 at 18:08 - Reply

      I love taking step by step photos, I do try and do it for every recipe but sometimes I get carried away cooking an forget to! I hope you enjoy it if you do try it :)

      • Holly Connors 22/05/2014 at 11:02 - Reply

        I always forget the in between photos so I have prep & completed only lol

  2. frugalfeeding 21/05/2014 at 11:39 - Reply

    That’s a truly beautiful tart – the consistency looks wonderful. Easily sliced!

    • Jo Blogs 21/05/2014 at 18:09 - Reply

      Thank you Frugs – it was a good set, not too firm but solid nonetheless. It was very well behaved when I sliced it!

  3. gottagetbaked 22/05/2014 at 05:56 - Reply

    First you get me dreaming about cake and now I’m dying for a giant slice of your beautiful tart! This looks fabulous, Jo. I love making quiches. They always taste better than anything I buy at the store and it’s an excellent way to clear out the fridge. You can throw almost anything in a quiche and it’ll taste awesome. Your crust (my favourite part) looks perfect.

    • Jo Blogs 22/05/2014 at 07:23 - Reply

      Shhh, don’t let daylight in on the magic – this tart was an excellent fridge clear out bake ;). Lol. Do give this bread dough crust a try next time you make quiche hun, it works better than you would think :D

  4. nkemdilim 24/05/2014 at 18:32 - Reply

    Ooooooh I love quice. Hot, warm cold ! Just looooove. Yours looks amazing. Made some too….you can have a look :-)

  5. annauk1 17/06/2014 at 14:34 - Reply

    One day I WILL try making a tart/quiche. I am worried beyond belief that I will end up with lovely ingredients sitting in inedible scrambled egg! :(
    This one looks so lovely and summery, Jo. :)

    • Jo Blogs 17/06/2014 at 18:36 - Reply

      I know you don’t like egg so I can see why you wouldn’t have tried one Anna. You can reduce it down a fair bit and still get a set – the cheese helps especially if served cold ;)

      • annauk1 17/06/2014 at 18:52 - Reply

        What would you say is the minimum egg amount to still get a set? (Sorry if this is an impossible question)

        • Jo Blogs 17/06/2014 at 18:55 - Reply

          You could try with two eggs in this recipe and see how it goes :). I wonder if a little bit of cornflour whisked into this savoury custard would work like custard powder, the sweet stuff….

          • annauk1 17/06/2014 at 20:13

            Ah, very clever idea! :)

  6. Angela 12/05/2017 at 17:41 - Reply

    I had never made a tart before with anything but a pastry case so was a little concerned about the pizza dough! I certainly shouldn’t have worried.. its so easy to make and tastes fab! I’m converted and actually prefer the pizza base. The flavours in the quiche work so well together, its really very delicious and I will definitely be making it again!

    • Just Jo 12/05/2017 at 19:32 - Reply

      Yeah! Oh thank you Angela for trying the recipe and taking the time to leave me some feedback. I am delighted you loved this quiche and I loved seeing your piccies of it on IG – a sterling job you did indeed. I’ve not used shortcrust in years for savoury tarts and quiches – why anyone wants all that heaviness from so much extra butter when the fillings are so often rich and creamy is beyond me. Happy to have a pizza dough convert with me!

Leave A Comment

Every Nook & Cranny favicon

Subscribe today and never miss a recipe!

Join the EN&C mailing list today!